Here be spoilers. I am reviewing the first 3 books of the series simultaneously, so there will be spoilers for them. You are safe for later books though.
This series revolves around Atticus, a magic-weilding Druid. He’s the last Druid, he’s able to stand toe-to-toe with gods and survive, he looks young but is thousands of years old, he’s… a male Mary-Sue (aka Gary-Stu). Seriously. It was easy to ignore at first, but the further I got into the series, the more it bugged me.
First, the age thing. He’s thousands of years old, but somehow knows how to talk, dress, and act to fit in. In real life, most older people are not up-to-date with modern technology and trends, and yet Atticus, who is many times their age, seems to have no such problem. He even teases Lief the vampire about seeming antiquated, and Lief is like half of Atticus’ age.
Then the power thing. A couple of times the book tries to describe the boundaries of Atticus’ power, and try to make him sound limited, but he killed a god. He also managed to create a magical necklace that other gods hadn’t even thought to make. At the point where I finally stopped reading, there was nothing Atticus had encountered that seemed like a real threat. Not even the Bacchants; by the time they showed up, it felt like they were just an excuse to have Atticus make a promise that would lead to the next book.
The female representation isn’t the best. I wouldn’t go so far as to say it’s sexist, but a lot of it is shallow and/or stereotypical. There were no female characters that I identified with or liked. Almost all of the women were beautiful or sexy, except for a funny one, a couple of older ones, and maybe some evil ones. Granted, this is true to some extent for the male characters too, but the main character is male, so it doesn’t feel as glaring.
Were the books all bad? No. There were some good points. Atticus is able to communicate with his dog, and his dog is funny. In the first book the dog is obsessed with poodles, but overall his thoughts are amusing. The idea of all the various gods being alive isn’t original to this book, but it is entertaining (most of the time). There’s witty banter and quips that are funny when in the right dosage, though sometimes the author drags it out.
Overall the first one was pretty decent – maybe a 6.5 or 7 out of 10 – but the second one wasn’t as good, and obviously I didn’t finish the third one. The books may not be very original, but they still have some fun ideas to play with. If you like supernatural stories and don’t mind Gary-Stus, you’ll probably get further in the series than I did.